The journey from consuming raw eggs to drinking protein shakes highlights the trend where individuals aiming to enhance muscle growth are often advised to increase their protein intake substantially. But what is the ideal amount, and what are the best ways to ingest it?

Sophia Moulson, a 21-year-old fitness influencer from West Sussex, took her health seriously at 19 after facing challenges with weight.

“I often sought comfort in food, which led to a cycle of poor self-esteem and negative body image. It finally dawned on me that I needed to take charge of my health, both physically and mentally,” Moulson shares.

At first, she joined a gym with the primary goal of losing weight. However, as she progressed, she developed a passion for building muscle. “Experiencing the strength gains was incredibly empowering, and each small milestone inspired me to keep pushing forward,” she explains.

A crucial aspect of Moulson’s journey was her focus on nutrition, particularly the role of protein in muscle building. Being a vegetarian, she initially struggled to meet her protein needs through food alone, prompting her to incorporate protein powders. “Though a balanced diet could suffice, it required meticulous planning and time. Protein powders became a practical solution, especially with my hectic lifestyle,” she states.

While bodybuilders of the past were famous for their hefty consumption of steak and raw eggs, today’s focus has shifted towards protein powders and customized diets. But is there truly a necessity for such high protein consumption to achieve strength gains? What is the optimal method for intake?

Linea Patel, a Sports Dietitian at Pure Sports Medicine in London, elaborates on the multifaceted functions of proteins in the body. As proteins are digested, they break down into amino acids, the building blocks necessary for creating various bodily proteins. These include muscles, enzymes, hemoglobin, and keratin found in hair and skin. In fact, the human body utilizes over 20,000 different proteins, fulfilling a variety of essential roles.

However, protein requirements can differ significantly among individuals based on factors such as age, body composition, and activity level.

“In the UK, the governmental recommendations suggest that sedentary adults should aim for approximately 0.8g of protein per kilogram of body weight,” Patel explains. “For instance, a person weighing 70kg [154lbs] would need about 56g of protein daily.”

“In my practice, especially with women going through menopause or high-performance athletes, I often observe that they may not consume sufficient protein relative to their activity levels or to sustain their muscle mass during various life stages,” Patel points out. This highlights the need for a tailored approach to protein intake.

Healthcare professionals often advocate obtaining protein primarily from food sources. For those following vegan diets, this may include incorporating more nuts, seeds, soy products, and legumes like beans and lentils. Vegetarians may also consume eggs, yogurt, and certain cheeses, while omnivores can increase their intake of meat and fish.

For many individuals, achieving their protein targets involves experimenting with various foods. Nonetheless, not everyone has the time or resources to acquire enough protein solely through diet.

“Despite the theory that one can fulfill protein requirements through a diverse diet rich in lean meats, dairy, and legumes, this approach may not be practical for everyone without additional protein supplementation,” emphasizes Cyriac Abby Philips, a liver specialist from Rajagiri Hospital in Kerala, India.

Lauren Manaker, a dietitian based in Charleston, South Carolina, states that protein powders present a convenient option, particularly for those leading busy lives or lacking access to whole food protein sources.

“After integrating plant-based protein powders into my routine, hitting my protein goals became significantly easier. I explored different brands and discovered that lean protein powders or whey protein were ideal for me due to their low calorie count but high protein content,” Moulson adds.

However, it’s critical to note that some protein powders may contain misleading labels and potentially harmful contaminants. A recent study conducted by Philips and other researchers explored protein powders sold in India, revealing discrepancies in protein content and the presence of heavy metals and harmful substances.

In 2018, a nonprofit organization known as the Clean Label Project published findings about contaminants in popular protein powder brands within the U.S. They examined 134 products for various toxins and found alarming levels of heavy metals and other harmful chemicals, indicating a significant health risk for consumers.

As protein powders fall under food categories rather than pharmaceuticals, regulatory scrutiny tends to be less stringent. This has raised concerns regarding the safety and quality of these supplements.

When it comes to muscle development, it is indeed possible to fulfill protein requirements through diet alone, though it may demand considerable effort and organization. To achieve daily protein goals effectively, it’s helpful to include a protein source in every meal, advises Patel.

“Aim for approximately 20-30g (0.7-1.1oz) of protein in every meal,” suggests Patel. This could involve consuming two eggs or some Greek yogurt topped with nuts, a chicken breast, or a fist-sized piece of tofu.

“For instance, you might enjoy two eggs on sourdough toast with avocado and seeds; in this case, the eggs serve as the primary protein source,” Patel elaborates. “In a rice and lentil dish, the lentils would be the dominant protein.”

If you opt for protein supplementation, it’s vital to select options with minimal harmful substances. Focus on high-quality proteins while avoiding those with numerous additives, advises Philips.

“Avoid blended protein options that incorporate herbal ingredients, as they come with elevated risks of contamination,” he cautions.

Manaker reminds consumers to conduct thorough research to bypass unnecessary components. “Select protein powders composed of high-quality ingredients, featuring minimal fillers or synthetic sweeteners. Choose brands that emphasize transparency in their ingredient sourcing and processing,” she recommends.

Manaker also advises checking the source of protein in the supplementation. It’s essential to read labels to differentiate between whey, casein, soy, and other plant or animal sources. “Select a protein source that aligns with your dietary practices and any allergies or sensitivities you may have,” she adds.

The timing of protein consumption can also impact its effectiveness, according to Manaker. “Consuming protein within 30 minutes to an hour post-workout is often advisable to maximize the body’s nutrient absorption capabilities during this timeframe,” she states.

Moreover, even though protein powders can be beneficial, it’s crucial to not let them substitute whole foods entirely. “A diet rich in nutrient-dense whole foods should be the mainstay, with supplements serving only to enhance a balanced eating regimen. Relying solely on protein powders might lead to insufficient intake of other vital nutrients,” warns Manaker.

With the availability of protein supplements and food options, many individuals may consume more protein than necessary. For instance, while the average adult requires around 45-56 grams of protein per day, many in the UK commonly consume between 75-100 grams. Although crucial for muscle development and overall wellness, excessive protein intake can carry potential health risks.

“Consistently high protein intake can impose stress on the kidneys,” Manaker explains. “Those with existing kidney issues should exercise particular caution.”

Additionally, a sudden increase in protein consumption, especially from powders, might cause digestive issues such as bloating and constipation. “Pay attention to how your body responds as you adjust your protein levels,” Patel suggests.

It’s easy to overindulge when using protein powders. “As a rule of thumb, I wouldn’t recommend exceeding 80g per day from protein powders,” Patel cautions. “Even 80g is excessive for most people, as it may replace whole foods rich in vitamins and minerals necessary for health. Generally, I advise my clients to aim for 20-40g of protein powder daily.”

Problems arise, particularly when an individual’s nutritional focus is narrowed excessively on protein, neglecting vital micronutrients from fruits, vegetables, and carbohydrates. A balanced diet is essential for overall well-being.

To maximize nutrition while weight training, include quality carbohydrates and prioritize essential micronutrients such as Vitamin D, magnesium, iron, and Omega-3 fatty acids. “These are critical for muscle function, bone health, and energy levels. Aim to include fruits, vegetables, and oily fish in your diet at least once per week,” Patel emphasizes.

While sufficient protein is vital for muscle strength enhancement, it forms just one aspect of overall wellness. “The other pillars include physical activity, adequate training, and quality sleep,” Patel concludes.

For reliable advice on improving health and wellbeing grounded in scientific research, subscribe to the
Health Fix newsletter, while
The Essential List
 delivers carefully curated features and insights.

To stay updated on more science, technology, environment, and health topics from the BBC, follow us on
Facebook,
X and
Instagram.