Mike Modano is one of the few individuals in the sport of American hockey who has witnessed its transformation firsthand.

Hailing from just outside Detroit, Modano emerged as a standout in minor hockey before moving on to the WHL in Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, where he played during his junior years—the premier league for American teens at the time.

Selected first overall in the 1988 NHL Draft, Modano spent his initial four seasons with the Minnesota North Stars. After the team relocated to Dallas in 1993-94, he led the Stars to their first Stanley Cup victory—the first by a team based in the U.S. Sunbelt.

Modano observed how hockey significantly surged in Texas following that 1999 win, as interest in the sport expanded to other non-traditional areas across the country throughout the following decade.

Fast forward 25 years, and the number of American children participating in hockey has skyrocketed. The NHL now boasts a record number of American players as well.

Now, Team USA is positioned as the favorite at the upcoming 4 Nations Face-Off, featuring captain Auston Matthews from Scottsdale, Arizona. This event marks the first best-on-best competition in nearly a decade.

Having retired in 2011 as the NHL’s all-time leading scorer among U.S.-born players, Modano celebrated a gold medal victory at the 1996 World Cup and a silver at the 2002 Olympics. He admits that watching this new generation of Team USA compete on the international stage feels markedly different.

No longer are the Americans the perennial underdogs, as they often were throughout his career.

Modano attributes this change to not only the influx of new talent but also the dedicated efforts by USA Hockey over the past two decades to promote the sport.

EXPLORE MORE

The curious case of the Canadian goalie: Inside the freefall

American players are no longer heading to Canadian junior leagues for opportunity; they are thriving at home and are advancing like never before.

“There’s an overwhelming amount of talent to choose from,” Modano noted regarding the players representing the U.S. at the 4 Nations event. They will kick off their campaign against Finland in Montreal this Thursday. “Now, there’s an expectation and a bit of pressure on these players, which is a positive development.”

“There’s always some stress before tournaments. It’s not just hoping to perform decently; we’re no longer lagging behind Canada or Russia. Now we share the spotlight with these powerhouse teams.”

When Modano hoisted the Stanley Cup in Texas in 1999, the number of American players in the NHL was actually in decline, as European athletes started to dominate the league. That season, American players accounted for just 17 percent of all games played, while Canadians made up 54 percent.

Fast forward to this season, and the U.S. has nearly doubled its presence in the NHL, reaching 30 percent—an all-time record. Over the past two decades, the U.S. has made significant strides toward closing the gap with Canada.

The once far-fetched idea of American players overtaking Canadian talent—both internationally and within the NHL—has become a tangible possibility.

At the current pace, this could become a reality in just over ten years.

“Team USA is brimming with exceptional puck-moving defensemen,” Modano remarked on the 4 Nations roster. “The goaltending is impressive, and their forwards showcase significant skill.”

“If anything, they’re only poised to improve. We’re witnessing a gradual shift, where the balance is tipping, particularly against Canada.”

Here, we explore four key factors that suggest the U.S. could soon emerge as the premier hockey nation in the world—or may have already begun to do so.

EXPLORE MORE

Ranking the 4 Nations Face-Off rosters: America’s golden era is here

The NTDP Framework

By the mid-1990s, USA Hockey recognized it had a significant issue regarding the scarcity of elite talent available for its men’s national team.

While Hall of Famers like Modano, Brian Leetch, Brett Hull, Chris Chelios, Phil Housley, and Jeremy Roenick were still active, the depth of top-tier talent was thinning rapidly.

Take, for instance, the 1994 World Championships in Italy, where the U.S. suffered a crushing 8-0 defeat to Finland in the semifinals and subsequently lost the bronze medal match to Sweden. The top scorer for the U.S. that year was Craig Janney, who never made an NHL All-Star team, while Canada boasted a roster filled with future Hall of Famers.

After another disappointing quarterfinal exit at the 1995 Worlds against Canada, it was clear that a change was necessary.

“We weren’t winning internationally, and our output of NHL-caliber players wasn’t meeting expectations based on the number of players in the country,” said USA Hockey executive director Pat Kelleher. “So, we decided to innovate.”

The first move was recruiting Jeff Jackson, a two-time NCAA championship-winning coach, and Bob Mancini, who was the head coach at Michigan Tech, to devise a strategy to cultivate elite American hockey talent.

This initiative led to the establishment of the U.S. National Team Development Program (NTDP) in 1996. The program would form an under-18 team and an under-17 team, selecting the best players from their age groups to train centrally in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and address the country’s hockey talent gap.

The aim was to create what Kelleher termed “a finishing school for exceptional athletes.” Under Jackson’s leadership, the U18 team flourished, while Mancini directed the U17 team and oversaw player personnel. By the fall of 1997, both teams were competing against NCAA, USHL, and NAHL teams.

While the two coaches had considerable support from senior management, not all key stakeholders shared their vision. Many local coaches and parents were hesitant about USA Hockey recruiting top talents from their regions.

“Concerns about player recruitment reached down to grassroots levels,” Mancini recalled. “I was physically confronted in rinks, and coaches often opposed our efforts.”

Moreover, convincing parents to let their children relocate to Michigan was a considerable hurdle, as many were doubtful about the necessity of the move. Initially, only about 70 percent of targeted players joined the program.

“We were inadvertently losing promising talents to alternative paths,” Mancini noted. “Those were valid concerns.”

In the early years, there were no established schedules or facilities, and players had to stay with local families while completing high school. Mancini likened it to “building the aircraft while we were flying it.”

By the second year, the recruitment success rate rose to 80 percent, and by the third, it approached 90 percent. “Suddenly, we were receiving calls from interested parents and agents,” Mancini remembered.

By 2000, the program had produced its first NHL No. 1 draft pick, goalie Rick DiPietro, followed by four more in successive years. In total, 99 players from the NTDP have become first-round picks—a testament to the program’s impact.

In 2004, the U.S. clinched its inaugural gold medal at the World Junior Championships with a roster predominantly featuring NTDP alumni. Since then, they have collected six additional titles, including recent wins in 2024 and 2025. Their presence on these rosters has continued to grow, reflecting immense international success.

“Previously, we hoped to contend for gold. Now, the expectations have matured,” Kelleher emphasized. “That’s a significant improvement.”

As the U.S. gears up for its first international best-on-best competition featuring NHL players since 2016, the roster includes 15 NTDP alumni, including captain Matthews, alternate captains Matthew Tkachuk and Charlie McAvoy, and starting goaltender Connor Hellebuyck.

“The program was integral to my development,” expounded Matt Boldy, Minnesota Wild winger and 4 Nations team member who participated from 2017-2019. “It provided everything—skills, conditioning, and camaraderie.”

Expanding Beyond Traditional Hubs

The diversity of regions represented in the 4 Nations roster illustrates how the U.S. has broadened its talent pool.

Traditionally, Team USA’s top-tier squads consisted mainly of players from the Three M states: Michigan, Minnesota, and Massachusetts. This year, however, the roster includes talent from states like Alaska, Arizona, Florida, Missouri, New York, Ohio, and Pennsylvania.

This shift is corroborated by an estimated increase of 100,000 players in the U.S. from 2000 to 2015, with substantial growth in states like California, Florida, North Carolina, Texas, Tennessee, Virginia, and Washington.

The presence of NHL teams in these regions has been a crucial factor, contributing to Stanley Cup victories in nine of the last 20 seasons (2004, 2006, 2007, 2012, 2014, 2018, 2020, 2021, and 2024).

“The support and engagement from NHL clubs have been immensely beneficial,” Kelleher acknowledged.

“The accessibility of the game has expanded dramatically for these young athletes,” Modano remarked. “As more players join the sport, we’re seeing an influx of elite talent in the NHL, junior leagues, and college hockey. The improvement is exciting.”

In the past three years, USA Hockey has added an additional 36 spots for national player development camps, increasing the total to 216. “We realized we were missing opportunities for promising players in various districts,” Mancini stated.

The future of talent is promising, with many emerging stars from these new markets, including Flames rookie of the year candidate Dustin Wolf from California, Maple Leafs power forward Matthew Knies from Arizona, and Senators defenseman Jake Sanderson from Montana.

USA Hockey’s Complementary Development Programs

In 2009, as the NTDP thrived as a junior elite pipeline, USA Hockey introduced the “American Development Model (ADM)”—aimed at maximizing player potential from a young age, starting with “learn to skate” initiatives for preschoolers.

The ADM emphasizes age-appropriate training and ongoing education for USA Hockey’s 60,000 registered coaches. This framework incorporated elements initially developed at the NTDP.

“We sought to establish a well-structured development system nationwide that stakeholders could rely on,” Kelleher remarked. “Simultaneously, we aimed to increase access, so more children could experience and develop in hockey—be it as a recreational player, high school athlete, collegiate player, or Olympic/Paralympic competitor.”

While the goal isn’t solely to produce a roster of American NHL talents, it has been an advantageous outcome. This approach has birthed “multiple player pathways,” offering various avenues for development.

While gaining acceptance into the NTDP may provide the most direct path to the NHL, alternative pathways are successfully producing talent.

Currently, there are nearly 300 American players in the NHL, with about 100 having emerged from the NTDP. The rest have made their mark through NCAA teams, the USHL, prep schools, or Minnesota high schools.

“The growth of elite talent in our pool is largely due to having various options for players seeking development,” Kelleher explained.

The diversity of the 4 Nations roster reflects this; out of the 23 selected players, eight took different routes, including Jets winger Kyle Connor, who was cut from the U17 team. After excelling in the USHL for three seasons, he spent a season at the University of Michigan before being drafted 15th overall by Winnipeg at 18. Eight years later, he leads all American players in NHL goals.

“Kyle Connor found a unique path to success and is now an NHL superstar,” Kelleher stated.

Mancini, now the assistant executive director of hockey development with USA Hockey, noted the profound effect of the ADM during national team tryouts. “In the initial days of the NTDP, we might have targeted 20 players. Now we’re reviewing 40, making it much harder to select because the talent pool has grown exponentially.”

“We’re not just increasing quantity; we’re enhancing quality.”

A New Generation of Goaltending Talent

The U.S. has also significantly strengthened its goaltending additions, making them frontrunners as they head into the 4 Nations competition.

With Russia absent from international play and Canada facing difficulties in producing top goaltenders, the U.S. boasts a clear advantage in this critical area.

The roster features standout goaltender Connor Hellebuyck, a Hart Trophy candidate and widely recognized as the best goalie globally. Joining him are Jake Oettinger from the Stars and Jeremy Swayman from the Bruins—ranking first, second, and thirteenth in NHL wins over the past four seasons.

While the U.S. has historically produced quality goaltenders such as Ryan Miller and Mike Richter, the current depth at this position is unprecedented.

In recent years, the U.S. has witnessed a surge in goaltending talent, largely fueled by the NTDP and an intensified focus on developing young goaltenders.

Similar to strategies employed in European nations, USA Hockey has prioritized increasing the number of goalie coaches in minor hockey. There is an ambitious goal of having over 10 percent of players as goaltenders by 2030, encouraging more kids to explore this vital position instead of specializing at an early age.

The ultimate objective is for American goalies to occupy 50 percent of the total minutes played in the NHL in the near future (currently at 23 percent).

According to USA Hockey’s goalie development director Steve Thompson, improved structures in youth and junior systems feeding into NCAA programs are yielding significant returns, allowing goaltenders crucially more time to refine their skills before transitioning to professional play.

All three American goaltenders at the 4 Nations gained valuable experience through U.S. junior leagues before spending multiple years in college. In contrast, Canada’s goalies transitioned directly from junior to professional hockey at a younger age.

“The extra time in college hockey enables our goalies to develop strength, resilience, and maturity before the pro levels,” Thompson added. “This has been a tremendous boon for our American goaltenders.”

This burgeoning success is providing the U.S. with a notable edge as the 4 Nations tournament approaches, with the Winter Olympics just one year away.

“It’ll be exciting to see how it all unfolds,” Modano remarked.

(Photo: Vitor Munhoz / 4NFO / World Cup of Hockey via Getty Images)